16 Comments
User's avatar
Anna's avatar

This is such a good read. Sharing with my son, who is a postdoc, ASAP.

Jolie Gan's avatar

Glad you enjoyed! Please report back with what his feedback was.

Anna's avatar

Of course!

Alexei Gannon's avatar

Certainly it's the economics that's the main problem here, not the culture? The interesting bit about declining birth rates is how you can't just pay people to have kids, but surely the success of high-paying AI labs (and before them, FAANG engineer jobs) is evidence that technical people are incentivized to do research/technical work by good pay.

Jolie Gan's avatar

When I talk about the culture, I'm heavily talking about academia (which is why the RFR is limited to number of PhDs/new PIs/outgoing PIs). If I'm right in assuming you're talking about labs like DeepMind, OpenAI, then yes, a large enough dollar sign will move almost anyone (Scale AI).

The academic culture in research remains low-status, especially in this economy, and to non-scientists. Even within academia, there's a lot of status and culture around what lab you're in, how much you could make in industry instead, etc.

Geetanjali Bendale, PhD's avatar

Brilliant synopsis of the current state of academia and research.

I think initiatives like FROs like this one can fade the lines between industry and academia and build a truly collaborative research enterprise.

(https://www.linkedin.com/posts/jennifer-kan_beyond-academia-should-scientists-launch-activity-7350901998843543553-2tSB?utm_source=share&utm_medium=member_ios&rcm=ACoAAAcxEPQB0UpETJDC6WbYylmy4K2pIKA2TZA)

Jolie Gan's avatar

Thank you! I think FROs are a great next step, although I'm of the stance that we're still too early to factor in how much they're going to disrupt where researchers go (hence why they're not calculated for here - future piece maybe?)

They're also quite limited as of right now (for example location-wise, based in California for the most part, and still pulling heavily from schools in the Bay [Stanford, UCSF, Berkeley]) but excited to see where they go.

Geetanjali Bendale, PhD's avatar

I agree its a little early for that. But being in academia right now, I do see a massive opportunity for a FRO like collaborative set up (re: industry, incubators, shared PhD students) beyond the walls of universities, where researchers can feel like they can go between the two without much resistance. The way it is right now, I think most feel like once they are out of academia, there is no way back. If we make that back and forth easier, it may change how we do research. You up for a collaborative article?

Jolie Gan's avatar

Send me a message!

Mike X Cohen, PhD's avatar

Well-written and thought-provoking. Thanks! (I'm in the statistic of tenured profs who voluntarily left academia, and I haven't regretted it.)

Jolie Gan's avatar

Thanks for the read! Glad you liked it - and thanks for sharing your story. Where did you end up taking your career/where are you now?

Mike X Cohen, PhD's avatar

I ran a neuroscience research lab in NL, then quit to start a company and do full-time teaching. I write books and make online courses (and I'm on Substack since one week!). It simultaneously feels very close to academia, and very far from the academy.

Kuan-lin Huang, PhD's avatar

Very interesting take & parallel; perhaps in some ways it's a good thing that there are cross-country competitions on PhDs to build their most advanced technologies. They shall all 10x their science funding. (shameless plug: https://drkuan.substack.com/p/america-weve-got-a-problem)

Corin Wagen's avatar

I think the risk–reward piece here is correct. Academic careers seem less appealing than ever: grants are hard to get, resources are scarce, and you have to labor in the postdoc mines for years before you can have substantial scientific independence to pursue your own ideas. In contrast, there are more non-academic funding mechanisms than ever.

Speaking personally, we've been able to pursue our research as a startup instead of through traditional academic mechanisms—fundraising has been easier, we can attract better / orthogonal talent (like software engineers), and we're still able to have students, collaborate, publish papers, etc. I don't know of any academic mechanisms where a 24-yo could have as much independence and research freedom as we have....

Jolie Gan's avatar

Truly a gift. I’ve just finished the book - Genentech, the beginnings of biotech - that outline just how hard it was for research to be commercialized and how taboo it was for work done in labs to spin out.

Curious what your thoughts are for the startup - are you planning on still having a foot in the academic door, or going all in operating it as a business independent of an institution, long/short term?

Corin Wagen's avatar

Nope, we're all-in on being a business! I think operating as a business is just strictly better, we have total freedom, we're not reliant on grants or academic politics, and we have more control over hiring / talent retention.