This is superb. A worthy roadmap of what is starting to feel like a movement in its infancy, as I look around me and listen to others.
Regarding your Open Question #2, I'm thrilled to read someone thinking about it, but —and it's surely my own personal bias—I'm finding the framing (respectfully) narrow. If science is being torn down in the West and we're playing for all the marbles, I feel we can be far more creative and ambitious than simply imagining a new scientific hegemon with scouts concentrating the best and brightest from regional nodes towards a central node. We have the technology to reinvent the idea of scientific hegemony itself, and even though realistically it might never happen, this is the time to dream alternate futures. Science operates across many registers and with different objectives across different contexts—multiple overlapping but distinct networks, maybe; I think you were gesturing towards that with "language hubs". We have a lot to learn from each others' networks in this way!
What a thoughtful response - you're absolutely right that the framing was quite narrow, still trapped in the old paradigm of "who becomes the next hegemon" when maybe the real question is "what comes after hegemony?"
The idea of multiple overlapping networks rather than a single center is fascinating. It reminds me of how the internet evolved: we kept expecting one protocol or platform to "win," but instead we got this beautiful mess of interconnected systems that somehow work together. Why should scientific progress be any different? The beauty of observing 21st century R&D is that we effectively get to apply the scientific method to institutions and systems and see how they each play out.
I'm curious what you envision when you say "reinvent the idea of scientific hegemony itself"? Are you thinking distributed autonomous research organizations? City-states of science? Something we don't even have language for yet?
Eeexactly regarding the Internet example; hadn't thought of that and it's spot on. In fact, I think that looking back on the history of technology, that's always been the case: different protocols, methodologies, conceptual frameworks, skill sets, lexicons, networks of individuals, etc. that overlap to greater or lesser degrees and coexist, each oriented at addressing problems specific to a community of people working with the same tools or facing the same problems. Part of the project of modern science is to integrate all these forms of knowledge into a single systematized body, which for centuries required geographical, political, and economic centralization of that endeavor.
However, it's precisely the same beautiful mess of the Internet that allows us to distribute that project across those same three axes. Doing this through open access knowledge/opencourseware, open source methods, crowdfunding, and public labs was the ultimate project of the Open Science movement of the early 2010s, a movement I've been revisiting in search of answers and motivation through this hellscape of a time. I'm clearly biased by the nostalgia for my teenage science years, but I think there's much inspiration to gather from the experiments that were done and the other paths science explored in the years since. Might have to write about it.
So what does that look like? I don't think there's a single answer, nor should there be. Science will continue changing, and as in any genetically resilient population, we need to maintain the diversity from which to draw from when moments of crisis like this happen. Just as different alternative models of research institutions or funding mechanisms are being tested right now, like the ones you've catalogued above, we should try different modes and degrees of decentralization across different axes.
...that said, "city-states of science" sounds badass and hits a historical weak spot of mine, haha. The idea of an "online place" like you explore with The Distressed Scientists Dept. (I tried my own years ago https://lab-squared.github.io/ ) has always felt generative to me. What would the essence of a city-state be for the purposes of science? In what ways can we capture that in a distributed fashion? What can and should we do that is more/not than what a city-state does? If we don't have language for that, we'll understand it from the differences, but using those generative frameworks like city-state is fantastic to bring it into being.
This is superb. A worthy roadmap of what is starting to feel like a movement in its infancy, as I look around me and listen to others.
Regarding your Open Question #2, I'm thrilled to read someone thinking about it, but —and it's surely my own personal bias—I'm finding the framing (respectfully) narrow. If science is being torn down in the West and we're playing for all the marbles, I feel we can be far more creative and ambitious than simply imagining a new scientific hegemon with scouts concentrating the best and brightest from regional nodes towards a central node. We have the technology to reinvent the idea of scientific hegemony itself, and even though realistically it might never happen, this is the time to dream alternate futures. Science operates across many registers and with different objectives across different contexts—multiple overlapping but distinct networks, maybe; I think you were gesturing towards that with "language hubs". We have a lot to learn from each others' networks in this way!
What a thoughtful response - you're absolutely right that the framing was quite narrow, still trapped in the old paradigm of "who becomes the next hegemon" when maybe the real question is "what comes after hegemony?"
The idea of multiple overlapping networks rather than a single center is fascinating. It reminds me of how the internet evolved: we kept expecting one protocol or platform to "win," but instead we got this beautiful mess of interconnected systems that somehow work together. Why should scientific progress be any different? The beauty of observing 21st century R&D is that we effectively get to apply the scientific method to institutions and systems and see how they each play out.
I'm curious what you envision when you say "reinvent the idea of scientific hegemony itself"? Are you thinking distributed autonomous research organizations? City-states of science? Something we don't even have language for yet?
Eeexactly regarding the Internet example; hadn't thought of that and it's spot on. In fact, I think that looking back on the history of technology, that's always been the case: different protocols, methodologies, conceptual frameworks, skill sets, lexicons, networks of individuals, etc. that overlap to greater or lesser degrees and coexist, each oriented at addressing problems specific to a community of people working with the same tools or facing the same problems. Part of the project of modern science is to integrate all these forms of knowledge into a single systematized body, which for centuries required geographical, political, and economic centralization of that endeavor.
However, it's precisely the same beautiful mess of the Internet that allows us to distribute that project across those same three axes. Doing this through open access knowledge/opencourseware, open source methods, crowdfunding, and public labs was the ultimate project of the Open Science movement of the early 2010s, a movement I've been revisiting in search of answers and motivation through this hellscape of a time. I'm clearly biased by the nostalgia for my teenage science years, but I think there's much inspiration to gather from the experiments that were done and the other paths science explored in the years since. Might have to write about it.
So what does that look like? I don't think there's a single answer, nor should there be. Science will continue changing, and as in any genetically resilient population, we need to maintain the diversity from which to draw from when moments of crisis like this happen. Just as different alternative models of research institutions or funding mechanisms are being tested right now, like the ones you've catalogued above, we should try different modes and degrees of decentralization across different axes.
...that said, "city-states of science" sounds badass and hits a historical weak spot of mine, haha. The idea of an "online place" like you explore with The Distressed Scientists Dept. (I tried my own years ago https://lab-squared.github.io/ ) has always felt generative to me. What would the essence of a city-state be for the purposes of science? In what ways can we capture that in a distributed fashion? What can and should we do that is more/not than what a city-state does? If we don't have language for that, we'll understand it from the differences, but using those generative frameworks like city-state is fantastic to bring it into being.
this is so deep. thanks for outlining all of it