Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Alec Liu's avatar

Really great to read. Just goes to show how much work goes into building sustainable institutions. When it’s done well, people just assume that’s how it’s been so that’s how it should always be. I wonder how a deep dive for other prizes, not in the sciences, like the Oscars, might be.

One thing I wonder about though is whether all the reasons given for the endurance of the Nobel are accurate. Pointing out its reluctance to endow more prizes as a reason could be true, but could the opposite not be true as well? That its enduring despite its limited exposure to different fields? The introduction of the economics prize hasn’t really diminished the status of the Nobel even if it isn’t technically a Nobel. There is of course a limit, (e.g. introduce 150 prizes and that’s probably too much brand dilution) but I don’t know if we can say that choosing to be conservative on this point is such a strong reason for its continued reputation. Many universities have historically been slow to move towards adding new departments, fields, etc. and in those gaps is when we see new institutions become prestigious and rise to the top.

Emily's avatar

Always great to have you back. Can’t wait to see where you take this and what changes are to come.

4 more comments...

Ready for more?