19 Comments
User's avatar
Jolie Gan's avatar

People are saying that the order will likely be struck down. Even if this happens, the volatility will be enough to make any rational person skeptical of trusting the US and electing for stability and certainty elsewhere.

sacheung's avatar

Wow. Extremely well written.

Saurabh Dalvi's avatar

Public Institutions Can’t Afford the Price yes it's true and with the rise of AI, it will affect academia badly but not to industry, maybe you will see switching to industry from academics in upcoming years

Jolie Gan's avatar

We'll see if industry can afford this as well. Definitely more so than academia, but still pale in comparison compared to tech/finance (speaking from biopharma)

Saurabh Dalvi's avatar

It's a debatable but my money on Nvidia and oracle, they are cooking nowadays

Jolie Gan's avatar

For industry, this will be less of a hit. It’s ironic because it was sold as a tax on tech. But unless NVIDIA, Oracle, Google, etc. also pivot into research, I’m concerned what this means for where research goes (or if early career talent will even choose to stay in academia/research, let alone the country)

Adele Lopes's avatar

Love the data you use to support your arguments in this very well-written piece. You are so right in saying that the overall volatility of the U.S. makes it very unattractive for new entrepreneurs or young careerists. That being said, there is also the TN visa for Canadians that might make it more possible to work in the biotech/pharma industry without a U.S. citizen status. I guess we'll see how long that visa lasts.

Jolie Gan's avatar

Canada and Singapore are two examples of countries with special visas like this. But given that 70% of H1B holders are from India (and many international students are from China), they'll be the talent share we lose fastest - and also the ones in countries best positioned to rival the US for R&D

Adele Lopes's avatar

Yes for sure. TN only covers Canadian and Mexican I think too. Def a heap of talent being left on the table and subsequently moving somewhere else to pursue dreams.

Jolie Gan's avatar

it also gives me some anxiety on how long the O1, TN, etc. are going to last. There's a real case where we see a flooding of the O1 and trade agreement changes that challenge these visas.

marshm's avatar

In time having a more diverse and global ecosystem for research and industry might prove to be a benefit for everyone. We have learnt that we shouldn’t put all our eggs into the US basket.

Ryan M Allen's avatar

The interpretation right now is that F-1 visa holders nor OPT would not have the fee. So should not discount the international student path. That is already how a good portion of H-1Bs come anyway. But yes, does send signals that we don't want foreigners here. Also the admin could seemingly reverse course on this interpretation tomorrow.

https://www.collegetowns.org/p/impact-of-100k-h-1b-fee-on-international

sacheung's avatar

Not sure if this is true. You have to file a new petition to get an H visa

Ryan M Allen's avatar

This is certainly the interpretation as of now. Even Trump allies are mad about it because they want students included. That could change though! https://x.com/AFpost/status/1970917767986446450

Ryan M Allen's avatar

I literally cited him and this in my article about it above. You should at least have a look if you want to know what's going on here.

News outlets have also picked me up for comment on the issue: https://www.universityworldnews.com/post.php?story=2025092515035958

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2025-09-25/stanford-columbia-hit-by-trump-administration-100-000-h-1b-visa-fees?srnd=undefined

Like I said, things may change, but the current interpretation is that international students already here on a visa are exempt.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 21, 2025Edited
Comment deleted
Jolie Gan's avatar

Exactly. This also has implications for healthcare where 26% of nurses, staffers, etc. are foreign. Blanket policies hurt more than they help.